Skip to content
बिहिबार · Thursday, 19 November 2026
Bhrikuti Academic Publications (BAP) emblem भृकुटी पुस्तक
Cover of Power without Law: The Supreme Court of Canada, the Marshall Decisions and the Failure of Judicial Activism

Power without Law: The Supreme Court of Canada, the Marshall Decisions and the Failure of Judicial Activism

Alex M Cameron

McGill-Queen's University Press

The Supreme Court of Canada decision in the Marshall case asserted sweeping Native treaty rights and generated intense controversy. In Power without Law Alex Cameron enlivens the debate over judicial activism with an unprecedented examination of the details of the Marshall case, analyzing the evidence and procedure in the trial court and tracing the legal arguments through the Court of Appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada. He argues that there were critical defects in the process – the successful argument at the Supreme Court of Canada was never tested in the lower courts, the Crown’s expert was precluded from testifying about a vital document, the Court’s analysis does not accord with the historical evidence, and the treaty rights are inconsistent with the colonial law of Nova Scotia. Concluding that the Marshall decision was the result of incautious judicial activism, Power without Law challenges us to reconsider the role of our courts in the Charter era.

  • English
  • 244 pages
  • Paperback

The book

About this book

The Supreme Court of Canada decision in the Marshall case asserted sweeping Native treaty rights and generated intense controversy. In Power without Law Alex Cameron enlivens the debate over judicial activism with an unprecedented examination of the details of the Marshall case, analyzing the evidence and procedure in the trial court and tracing the legal arguments through the Court of Appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada. He argues that there were critical defects in the process – the successful argument at the Supreme Court of Canada was never tested in the lower courts, the Crown’s expert was precluded from testifying about a vital document, the Court’s analysis does not accord with the historical evidence, and the treaty rights are inconsistent with the colonial law of Nova Scotia. Concluding that the Marshall decision was the result of incautious judicial activism, Power without Law challenges us to reconsider the role of our courts in the Charter era.

Details

At a glance

Language
English
Pages
244
Binding
Paperback
Published
2009 A.D
ISBN
9780773536104
Publisher
McGill-Queen's University Press

Same shelf

You may also like

Rs. 10,500× 5